Professional Critique Editing

Have Your Work Professionally Critiqued

Sign up for critique appointments is now closed.

Do you want to reach the next level in your writing? Come one important step closer to your publishing goals?

Consider a critique by a professional editor!

The following Critique Editors will be accepting submissions for a fee of $40.

What can you expect in return?

A thorough critique with comments and a follow-up fifteen-minute phone call or zoom session with the faculty member—a valuable opportunity for you to ask any clarifying questions. Choose your faculty member from the list below. Notice that each one has listed which genres they are interested in critiquing. We encourage you to look at their bios and books published to decide which one would be a good fit for your work. 

Format your manuscript as follows:

  • Double-space pages
  • 12-point font
  • One-inch margins all around
  • Page numbers

Limit the size of your submission, see the genre criteria below. If you send more than listed, your manuscript will not be critiqued.

  • All fiction: This includes YA, middle-grade and children’s chapter books as well as adult fiction. One page single-spaced synopsis along with the first nine double-spaced pages of your manuscript. Ten pages total.
  • Nonfiction: First ten pages of manuscript, all double-spaced. You may include 2-3 pages of outline in your ten pages if you wish. Ten pages total.
  • Devotions, Articles, Blogs: You may send up to three, each no more than three pages, all double-spaced. Nine pages total.
  • Picture Books:  Full manuscript.

You will submit your manuscript to the critique editor by email when notified.  In re: line write "Renewal 2022 Critique Submission

Submissions open on April 10th, 2022

You will be contacted via email with directions for how to submit your manuscript.

On the conference registration form you will be asked to indicate the editor you’d like as a reviewer. Payment for the critique will be collected as part of your registration payment.  We have only a limited number of openings, so be sure to register early while there's still a chance to take advantage of this special feature

Critique Editors

Karen Ball

Total of number critiques accepted: 10 7

Genres accepted: Y/A or Adult 

Status: Accepting Submissions

Melanie Dobson

Total number of critiques accepted: 4 2

Genres accepted: Adult Fiction

Status: Accepting Submissions

Nick Harrison

Total number of critiques accepted:  10 7 (in-person only)

Genres accepted: 

Non-fiction: Christian Living, Memoir, Biography or anything except no personal experience, prophecy (end times), or devotionals.

Fiction: Adult fiction, except no speculative fiction. No children’s fiction.

Status:  Accepting Submissions 

Josh Kelley

Total number of critiques accepted:  10

Genres accepted: 

Non-fiction, especially memoirs, Christian living, and Biblical studies.

Fiction: all general adult fiction, 

Status: Accepting Submissions

Rowena Kuo

Total number of critiques accepted:  108

Genres accepted: 

All fiction genres, speculative fiction, YA, middle-grade, and screenplays

Status: Accepting Submissions

Dena Netherton

Total number of critiques accepted: 4 2

Genres accepted: Suspense, romantic suspense or romance

StatusAccepting Submissions

Darlene Panzera

Total number of critiques Accepted:3

Genres accepted: Romance

Status: Accepting Submissions

Carolyn Rice

Total number of critiques accepted: 5 4

Genres acceptedNonfiction and devotions, articles or blogs

StatusAccepting Submissions

Ginny Yttrup

Total number of critiques accepted: 3

Genres acceptedAdult Fiction

StatusAccepting Submissions

Copyright © by NCWA. All rights reserved.

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software